Showing posts with label vegetarianism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label vegetarianism. Show all posts

Saturday, June 30, 2012

Jonathan Safran Foer's Eating Animals Also Turned Me Vegan

Finally, we get to veganism. It only took me 2+ years since starting this blog. (laziness) Though I'm technically no longer a greenhorn, it's important to remember the roots of why I made this choice. (Or some cheesy line about how I'll always be learning new things about veganism)

Learning

Well I was vegetarian for about 5 months. Cutting meat out of my life was effortless and I was going pretty strong. But I still felt like I wasn't doing enough. Veganism was always the obvious logical progression. I knew I would eventually get there, but giving up all animal products entirely, including eggs, dairy, honey, leather, wool, etc, seemed too difficult.

But then I read Eating Animals, which as Natalie Portman said in her Huffington Post piece:
Jonathan Safran Foer's book Eating Animals changed me from a twenty-year vegetarian to a vegan activist. I've always been shy about being critical of others' choices because I hate when people do that to me. I'm often interrogated about being vegetarian (e.g., "What if you find out that carrots feel pain, too? Then what'll you eat?").

I've also been afraid to feel as if I know better than someone else -- a historically dangerous stance (I'm often reminded that "Hitler was a vegetarian, too, you know"). But this book reminded me that some things are just wrong. Perhaps others disagree with me that animals have personalities, but the highly documented torture of animals is unacceptable, and the human cost Foer describes in his book, of which I was previously unaware, is universally compelling.

The human cost of factory farming -- both the compromised welfare of slaughterhouse workers and, even more, the environmental effects of the mass production of animals -- is staggering. Foer details the copious amounts of pig shit sprayed into the air that result in great spikes in human respiratory ailments, the development of new bacterial strains due to overuse of antibiotics on farmed animals, and the origins of the swine flu epidemic, whose story has gripped the nation, in factory farms.
Both Natalie's piece and the book she describes are well-written arguments anybody can relate to. When I read Eating Animals, there was one specific account, which was not an exaggeration, of the "kill room" in an industrial cow farm. It brought me close to tears how these cows are hung upside down with their jugulars slit. The cows are supposed to be knocked out beforehand, being hit in the head by a steel bolt. But sometimes they are left semi-conscious, on purpose, because they bleed out faster if their hearts are still pumping. Sometimes they are fully conscious, not having been knocked out at all. Even worse, sometimes the cows are pregnant; one worker described a cow actually giving birth while she was walking down the "kill alley."

As Foer details, "No jokes here, and no turning away. Let’s say what we mean: animals are bled, skinned, and dismembered while conscious. It happens all the time, and the industry and the government know it."


not a sarah mclachlan commercial.

I felt so guilty. This story and all the countless other ones like it are results of our demand for meat. And it's not really our fault. Most of us grew up eating animals, not thinking anything of it, certainly not where it comes from or how it's "produced." To us, it's just food that ends up on our plates and tastes good. And part of the ignorance is because of the factory farming machine, which does a really good job of hiding their practices and transforming this sacred ritual of animal eating into a faceless, processed product that you buy in neat little packages with fancy price tags on them.

Choices

But once we learn the truth, that's where it really counts. Not knowing is one thing, but indifference is a choice. I'm not saying we should all be vegans overnight, but I can't help but frown upon a person who learns about all this suffering and chooses to ignore it. "Eating meat is natural," or "Meat just tastes too good," or the ever-popular, "You need a balanced diet," are not valid arguments. But ultimately, I don't preach or try to convert anyone. I believe in freedom of choice. It would be nice if it was an informed-choice, but that's probably wishful thinking. You don't have to do the whole vegan thing, but at least cut down on meat consumption (we consume more meat than we ever have in our entire history).

So I've been vegan for a little over two years. I feel great and am more conscious of my health than ever before. For me, it's not just about not eating animals, it's about watching my carbon footprint, as well as good nutrition and exercise. Because, let's be real, you can be vegan by eating nothing but potato chips and french fries (not fried in lard) all day.

oh the many benefits of fresh fruit.

I read that Natalie Portman stopped being strictly vegan when she was pregnant. I was a little disappointed, but I understand. Whether she went back to being vegan, I don't know. I also read that Jonathan Safran Foer started promoting "happy" chickens, which I don't support. Terms like "cage-free"or "free range" are ambiguous at best, but that's a whole other blog post. But in any case, even if Natalie and Jonathan aren't vegans themselves, their arguments are still sound. And I leave you with this excerpt from Natalie's piece.
I remember in college, a professor asked our class to consider what our grandchildren would look back on as being backward behavior or thinking in our generation, the way we are shocked by the kind of misogyny, racism, and sexism we know was commonplace in our grandparents' world. He urged us to use this principle to examine the behaviors in our lives and our societies that we should be a part of changing. Factory farming of animals will be one of the things we look back on as a relic of a less-evolved age.

I say that Foer's ethical charge against animal eating is brave because not only is it unpopular, it has also been characterized as unmanly, inconsiderate, and juvenile. But he reminds us that being a man, and a human, takes more thought than just "This is tasty, and that's why I do it."
Love and Peace,
VG

Sunday, October 24, 2010

Why Vegetarian to Begin With?

As any vegetarian or vegan knows, the number one question is "How long?", followed by the more important, "Why?" Everyone's always interested in why. Not that I don't welcome the question. I just get tired of explaining. To me, it was more "Why not?"

The turning point for me was when my sister, a longtime vegetarian (current vegan), asked me out to dinner one night. Unsurprisingly, we got into a discussion about animals. I had just ordered a quiche that was made with ham. She was arguing against the unethical slaughter and treatment of animals. I, like so many others, valued humans above animals. I chose to argue pro-animal testing when it came to lifesaving treatments, such as HIV antiretrovirals, medicine that saves millions of lives every year. The utilitarian point of view. But I was just doing what many of us do, rationalizing. For example, did the treatment of HIV warrant or excuse the inhumane slaughter that goes on in factory farms? No, but somehow it made me feel better knowing not all animal testing was done in vain.

Generally speaking, we only do studies with humans after drugs have passed many initial tests done on other animals. I mean, we could test on human beings instead, but then we'd argue safety and ethics, etc., something not generally afforded to other animals. And while some of these drugs save lives, some don't. Some are very dangerous, even after they get approval. Imagine being the initial guinea pig. And it's not just drugs. There are cosmetics, most of which are unnecessary (and probably even harmful) that get tested on other animals. Is it all for the greater good?

So sitting at that dinner table, seeing my sister's sympathy, I didn't know what to say. I felt guilty. Here I was, a rational logical person doing something I knew was wrong. I could see she was impassioned just talking about it, even though she noted that she used to get even more moved. I decided I couldn't eat the quiche anymore.

But after that night, I continued to eat animals. Though I didn't stop looking into it. I wanted to know what exactly were the benefits of vegetarianism. As it turned out, plenty. I read a Guardian article about a study which indicated that vegetarians had lower rates of certain cancers.

Here are some quotes:

"Dr Rajendra Pachauri, chair of the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change – which last year earned a share of the Nobel peace prize – urged giving up meat at least once a week as a way of combating global warming. The UN's Food and Agriculture Organisation has estimated that meat production accounts for nearly a fifth of global greenhouse gas emissions."

"Annette Pinner, chief executive of the Vegetarian Society, said: 'It is widely recognised that a third of cancers are directly related to diet and what's interesting in this study is the findings on blood cancers. We wouldn't claim vegetarianism is a panacea for cancer but it is a step in the right direction.'"

That first quote introduced me to the Meatless Monday campaign. Rallying people to give up meat one day a week, to help cut down on all the energy and water (and carbon emissions) that go into the meat industry. It was an intriguing idea. I decided to give it a shot.

And if I was going to think eating fish was acceptable, boy was I wrong. I listened to an NPR interview with Daniel Pauly, a professor at the Fisheries Centre of the University of British Columbia, about our fishing industry. It was alarming to hear how disastrous it has been. Having to go further offshore and into deeper waters as fish in coastal waters started disappearing. Opting for smaller and uglier fish as we started fishing off all the bigger ones. Football stadium-sized nets that scoop up and destroy countless ecosystems, taking the seafood that they want and then chucking everything else back to die. It simply wasn't (and isn't) worth it.

Here's an excerpt from his New Republic article:

"In the past 50 years, we have reduced the populations of large commercial fish, such as bluefin tuna, cod, and other favorites, by a staggering 90 percent. One study, published in the prestigious journal Science, forecast that, by 2048, all commercial fish stocks will have 'collapsed,' meaning that they will be generating 10 percent or less of their peak catches. Whether or not that particular year, or even decade, is correct, one thing is clear: Fish are in dire peril, and, if they are, then so are we."

So I was sold. There was the health aspect, the environmental aspect and the animal suffering bit. It was sound reasoning. My first Meatless Monday wasn't as hard as I thought it'd be. I guess when you have morals on your side and believe in something, the will power comes naturally. So much so that the next day I continued to go meatless. Then that night, I grilled some chicken, but as I took the first few bites, it wasn't as rewarding as I imagined it would have been. Because my morals didn't suddenly disappear. And I felt guilty because I knew I should and could continue being vegetarian. So I did.

I mean, this isn't meant to convince or convert anybody. So if you're reading this, don't get defensive. Many times, people have asked me why, and when I explain my reasoning, they get defensive when I was looking for an argument (though I understand that they feel indirectly attacked since they are pro-meat). I'm just reflecting on my journey here. Most vegetarians or vegans I know used to love and probably still would love the taste of meat. There's no denying that it's tasty, but that taste isn't worth all the pain that goes into it. Not in my mind. And yes, I always hear the "eating meat is natural" argument. Yes, it is. I always acknowledge that. But that doesn't mean we have to. Not to mention, the whole "natural" argument is unconvincing. Humans do all the most "unnatural" things in the world. Industrialization, Airplanes, Medicine, Ipods. Just to name a few. Yet we welcome those things without any pause.

Moreover, whenever people brought up "not getting enough protein" or "needing a complete diet", I always felt as if I was the first vegetarian in history. Like I was going to die not eating meat. Which was also kind of insulting, because sometimes these were people who knew me, and suddenly they didn't trust me to have made this decision with the proper research and education. Meanwhile, they've got nothing but "common sense" on their side. But I'm getting too ranty, so I'll just say, the list of many an intellectual and healthy (and in some cases bodybuilding or MMA-fighting) vegetarian/vegan is long and plentiful.

In any case, if there's anything you should take away from any of this, it's this nifty Michael Pollan adage: "Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants."

Love and Peace,
VG

Friday, October 8, 2010

Michael Pollan the foodie?

Over the course of that next year, I got really interested in food. More so than usual. I had always been interested in food. When my brother and I weren't being lazy and ordering takeout (or when we ran out of money), we cooked for ourselves because we were latchkey kids.

My newfound interest in food, specifically the food industry, came after I listened to an NPR interview with Michael Pollan. He had written an open letter to the next president. It called for food reform and perhaps a "farmer in chief." In the interview, he brought up some key points about the disconnect we had with our food, the troubles with food subsidizing and all the cheap unhealthy calories running our country. He also points out some ways we can make it better for everybody and the land we farm on. It's well worth a listen if you are interested in food.

I would thank him for piquing my interest in our food industry. His book, In Defense of Food (or the shorter, quicker, Food Rules), is a great read because it snaps a lot of common sense back into the way we should be thinking about eating. I'd recommend that as well.

In any case, I started wondering what a foodie was. There isn't an official definition for the term, but most people confuse it with the term gourmet. Gourmets are people who want to eat the best food out there, food connoisseurs, if you will. Picture typical snobby food critics, no offense (not all food critics are snobby). Whereas foodies are just people who are really interested in all the makings behind food, the science, politics, etc.

So was Michael Pollan a foodie? And by that regard, was I starting to become one myself?

Whatever it was, I continued to listen in on the conversations about food, such as the local food movement, organics, ethical animal slaughter and of course vegetarianism.

Wednesday, August 4, 2010

Heartbreak and Vegetarianism

It was the summer of 2008. I was in the middle of a bad breakup, and therefore a complete mess, as expected. The lack of control over my life bothered me the most. I couldn't stop myself from calling her, drinking, smoking, throwing away money. My willpower was depleted. So in an effort to regain a grasp on my life, and in "preparation" of cutting myself off from her, I set a few short-term goals. I wanted to give up cigarettes, coffee, alcohol and meat for two weeks. Yes, all at once. I don't know what it's like to withdraw from hard drugs, but I imagine my experiment, given my disheveled state at the time, could be at least a 7 on a 1-10 difficulty scale. Though it may have been mostly psychological.

I forget if I was actually able to do all four things concurrently. But I will tell you about giving up meat. It's not easy. I loved it all. You don't realize how much of a centerpiece meat is in every meal until it's not. I watched jealously as others chowed down on meat, even at a place like Ikea where my friends ate the signature Swedish meatballs and I had a lousily made veggie wrap (which isn't a knock on all veggie wraps, just theirs. veggie wraps are awesome if you actually put some effort into it).

My brother supported and joined my temporary vegetarianism, though I must confess that under his suggestion, we allowed seafood. I would frown upon that now since it's not true vegetarian. But pesco-vegetarianism is a challenge in itself. And it's not like I had seafood every meal those two weeks. This was when I first tried falafel. Oh, thank goodness for the almighty falafel. Crispy, zesty lumps of vegan goodness. For that reason, Oasis in Williamsburg, Brooklyn will always be dear to me.

Anyway, I didn't experience any veggie stigma, but I'm guessing it may be because I told everyone it was only temporary. That seemed to bring expressions of relief which I didn't realize at the time.

"Oh, you're not going to give meat up forever, are you?"

"No, just two weeks."
"Oh, okay. Good." / (Phew!)

So the two weeks went by without a hitch. After that I "broke" and had some grilled chicken, which frankly wasn't even that good.

Also, vegetarianism doesn't cure heartbreak.

Friday, July 23, 2010

Pre-Vegetarian: Running into Peter Singer

Five years before I would even consider dabbling in vegetarianism
myself, I read a Peter Singer essay as part of an ethics class I was
taking in college. I had no idea who Singer was or the groundwork he
had laid for animal rights, let alone that his essay would be a
cornerstone to my lifestyle change (I choose not to use the word
conversion here, even though it is suitable, because of the negative
connotations).

"All Animals Are Equal" by Peter Singer. His argument was a bit of an
eye opener even though anyone could come to the same conclusion using
common sense. It went into drawing comparisons between animals and
slaves, women and infants. In the end, it was simple. If you believe
that animals feel pain (which they most certainly do) and you don't
want to contribute to that pain and suffering, then you shouldn't eat
animals.

At the time, I knew it was the right thing to do. But giving up
anything, let alone meat, isn't easy. The moral implications alone
weren't compelling enough. I did however learn to respect those who
were strong enough to abstain from animals and animal products because
contrary to what a lot of people think, most vegetarians/vegans do not
hate the taste of meat. They probably loved eating meat just as much
as anybody. I know I did.

Which is why It would take me five years to revisit Peter Singer.

Wednesday, April 7, 2010

Why Am I Here and Why Does It Matter?

My experience with veganism is still new since it's only been a couple of weeks, but I sure have read and heard an abundance of different remarks and criticisms, either ignorant, good-intentioned or both. My goal here is not to answer all the naysayers who make hateful comments (of which, most are embarrassingly uninformed). It's also not to support those who force their views, no matter how ethical, onto others. However, I will dispel common myths and cheer on good-hearted activists.

My goal here is personal and communal. Obviously, it's a blog for me to reflect and sort through the conflicts and issues, "woes" if you will, that come up. Through that, though, I hope it clears confusion and resolves arguments that others may have. I only ask that you keep an open mind, and to seek out your own information, objectively. Please don't make the silly mistake of searching for just the evidence that supports your theory, while ignoring opposing views. Of course, if along the way, you need a friend to talk all things vegan, feel free to reach out.

I'm not completely vegan yet, in the sense that I haven't given away all my non-vegan clothing yet, though I made a healthy start. But even then, it's tough to be 100% vegan. Sometimes you can't get around it, as I'm quickly learning. Did you know that everyday dental floss or your car's rubber tires may not be vegan? But my aim isn't to adhere as strictly as possible to preset rules. That shouldn't be anybody's aim for anything in life. People who buy into a system of beliefs shouldn't do so mindlessly. Any "rule" of the system should be questioned. Why do you do the things you do? What are the reasons and benefits? Who gets hurt? Is it ethical? What I've learned just from the first few days was how conscious a lifestyle veganism can be, if you're truly inquisitive and curious, or if you care about what you consume or purchase and how it affects everything around you.

With so much going on in the world, so many big issues, real struggles, the life-threatening kind, many wonder why this lifestyle choice even matters. You may even think it doesn't matter at all. Well then you'd be misunderstanding it. Quite the opposite. In the first place, small choices you make at the register drive the economy. How the economy affects the world and foreign relations, that connection you should already know. Second, how you treat your body affects your overall health, your ability to contribute to said economy and the price you pay for health care (or the price your neighbor pays for your health care and vice versa). These are just two very broad points about how what you do matters, how one person makes a difference. And it's the lesson we learn as children that we stop believing in somewhere along the way.

love and peace,
VG